Verified Review icon check navigate-up navigate-left navigate-right expand mail svg-lightning svg-24hr svg-house svg-sleeps svg-bedrooms svg-bathrooms svg-stay svg-toilet calendar svg-report-flag pet-dog svg-multiunit
Book Online or call HomeAway Booking Assistance 888-640-7927
Book Online or call HomeAway Booking Assistance 888-640-7927

Beautiful Renovated Victorian Farmhouse with Pool

Bedrooms 5
Half Baths1
Property type farmhouse
Minimum Stay 3 nights


Half Baths
Minimum Stay
3 nights

About the property

Situated within easy walking distance to Shelter Island’ famous Sunset Beach, this beautiful house has been painstaking restored to its former glory. Whilst retaining its original character, it now offers top-of-the line amenities. The main house consists of a light filled living-room, study/children’s playroom, kitchen with top-of-the line appliances – sub-zero fridge, Viking range and dishwasher – and a half bath/mud room. Upstairs are two double bedrooms, one with twin beds, and a single bedroom. A beautiful bathroom includes a claw-foot bath tub with separate shower.

The pool house consists of a cathedral-ceiling main room with a queen bed, a bunk room and stunning bathroom with shower.

The house and pool house have both been decorated with great care. It is filled with beautiful and comfortable furniture and great art. However as parents of three small children they have been careful at the same time to make the house extremely practical.

Garden: The house’s historic beauty is matched by that of the stunning herbaceous English gardens that the property sits within. In addition to a beautiful 46x18 foot pool, the garden offers an outdoor shower, shady pergola dining area, charcoal barbecue, fire pit, front porch with swing, tire swing, vegetable garden, vineyard (perhaps the world's smallest!) children’s wooden playhouse and sand boat. The pool is fully enclosed and secure from the rest of the garden. The entire property is fenced and gated. In addition the garden is surrounded with a deer fence, helping keep the ticks at bay

Location: The house is situated within easy walking distance from both the Heights and Crescent Beach, and thus many of the islands best restaurants and bars, including Sunset Beach and Maison Blanche. For ice- cream lovers, it is a one-minute walk to the island's famous Tuck Shop. It is a two-minute drive/ ten-minute walk to the shops and attractions of the Heights and Dering Harbor, a five-minute drive to the IGA supermarket. post offices, banks, center shops and recycling center.

More Details

Pom Shillingford
Member since: 2011
Speaks: english
Response time:
Within 2 days
Response rate:
Calendar last updated:
February 24, 2017

About Pom Shillingford

We are an English couple with three children, ages 10, 9 and 6. After 15 years in Manhattan we moved to Litchfield County in NW Connecticut in September 2012.

Pom Shillingford purchased this farmhouse in 2002

Why Pom Shillingford chose Hamptons

Despite having fallen completely in love with Shelter Island, when we bought this property we actually had no intention of buying a house in the US, let alone one on Shelter Island. It was our first summer on Shelter Island and we had been part of a house share four houses further up Menantic Road. Every visit we had walked by our-now house which had a little hand-painted sign hanging outside saying 'Home For Sale By Owner'. On our last weekend of the season, while heading off on a bike ride, I said to my husband, 'Let's just be nosy and go and see what the inside looks like'. We knocked on the door, were given a tour and 45 minutes later made our offer. Two weeks later, having still only paid our 10% deposit, we moved in with nothing but a bed, two garden chairs and a bottle of champagne in the fridge, all left by the wonderful previous owners. While our decision might rank as record low in levels of forethought, In terms of the happiness, pleasure, comfort and fun it has subsequently bought us, it was the best decision we have ever made.

Shelter Island is a unique and magical place to spend time. We believe our house to be a pretty unique home from which to enjoy it.

What makes this farmhouse unique

Although this is our second home, it is still very much our home and we spend a significant part of the year at the house. As such it is furnished and equipped to a level of comfort and convenience beyond that of a year-round rental property. When we bought the house it had just been beautifully renovated - at least on the surface!. We have spent the preceding years replacing the more prosaic parts of the house- the roof, the well, the septic, the boiler, the electrics etc etc as well as building the pool house and pool. Despite starting with only a few sticks of furniture- and continually having our decorating budget desecrated by the need for working utilities - the house is now beautifully and simply decorated in a way sympathetic to its style and the setting. It is however furnished in a way that can cope with three young children and their friends - slipcovers that wash, surfaces that wipe. The house was completely redecorated in the Fall 2013 and we replaced many of the appliances with new top-of-the-line versions. As a keen cook, and one who frequently cooks for large numbers - the kitchen is equipped with everything all but a top professional chef could hope. Sharp knives, a wide selection of decent pots, a working processor, a KitchenAid mixer, every type of bakeware and enough matching plates and glasses to serve off.

When we bought the property the whole garden was row after row of vines. While only a few of these still remain, the huge advantage of this was the property is completely fenced - so deer out, children in. We replaced the vines with a fenced and hedged pool, an outside dining area and english-style herbaceous landscaping. There is also a tire swing, wooden playhouse and sand boat at the end of the garden. No deer mean that plants - roses, hostas, tulips- which would normally be devoured for breakfast, flourish here. It also means that, combined with the monthly spray, our garden tick population is greatly reduced.


5/5 -
(2 traveler reviews)

Beautiful Renovated Victorian Farmhouse with Pool
average rating of 5.0 based on 2 reviews

Can't improve on perfection

  • 5 of 5

This was truly the most charming home I have stayed in from Florida to Maine. There were four of us women, but we plan to come back with our families, because there was plenty of room, and lots of fun for the children we left at home...a charming playhouse in the large backyard, and the pool...what a treat. The sun warmed it up so there was no need for the heater. Our favorite spot was under the pergola with a bottle of wine. The kitchen was supplied with the best of cooking, baking, and serving ware. Add to this luxurious bedding, open windows, morning birdsong, and new flowers blooming in the beds each day (oh those roses!), and you'll understand why we sometimes opted to stay "home" rather than explore the delights of the area. Thanks, Pom, for sharing your bit of paradise with us.

  • Submitted: Jul 2, 2016
  • Stayed: Jun 2016
  • Source: HomeAway
Did you find this review helpful?
0 0

Beautiful, charming home

  • 5 of 5

We had the pleasure of spending 10 wonderful days at this fully updated, charming farmhouse. The house was extremely well maintained and the English gardens are spectacular. The beds were extremely comfortable, with crisp white bedding and the kitchen was well stocked. The children spent hours in the large, private pool. The home is extremely well located to walk to sunset (crescent) beach and Shelter Island Heights and is also close to the central part of town.

There are so many great things to do in Shelter Island: beach, hiking, biking, kayaking, mini-golf, farmer's market, great restaurants and all of it was just minutes away.

The owner was very responsive and helpful and made us feel at home. We would love to rent this house again.

  • Submitted: Jul 9, 2014
  • Stayed: Jun 2014
  • Source: HomeAway
Did you find this review helpful?
1 0


North Fork Table
The Frisky Oyster
The American Hotel
Southold Fish Market
Vine Street Cafe
Antique Carousel
Sunset Beach
Blue Canoe Oyster Bar
Rams Head Inn Restaurant
Nearest Barpub
0.25 Miles
Sunset Beach
Nearest Ferry
1 Miles
North'South Ferry
Nearest Golf
0.25 Miles
Shelter ISland Country Club
Nearest Train
2 Miles
Greenport to NYC?hampton Jitney
Nearest Restaurant
0.25 Miles
Maison Blanche
Nearest Beach
0.25 Miles
Sunset Beach


Rates & Availability

Shelter Island Farmhouse Rental Rates

Rental Basis:
per property
Owner accepts payment in:
Convert Currency
Rate Period Nightly Weekend Night Weekly Monthly Event
My Standard Rate
3 night minimum stay

Additional information about rental rates

Housekeeping, garden maintenance and weekly pool service is included. Propane usage for pool heater is not included and will be calculated and charged at the end of visit.
Deposit fully refundable up to 60 days before arrival.

Owner's Cancellation Policy

100% refund if canceled at least 60 days before arrival date.
Enter dates for accurate pricing
Send a Message Send a Message


Shelter Island Farmhouse Accommodation and Amenities

Property Type:
  • farmhouse
  • Guests provide their own meals
  • Housekeeper Included
Floor Area:
  • 1800 sq. ft.
Location Type:
  • Rural
  • Away From It All
  • Family
  • Romantic
  • Sports & Activities
  • Air Conditioning ...
  • Clothes Dryer ...
  • Garage
  • Heating
  • Internet
  • Iron & Board
  • Linens Provided
  • Living Room ...
  • Parking ...
  • Washing Machine ...
  • Coffee Maker ...
  • Dishes & Utensils ...
  • Dishwasher ...
  • Kitchen ...
  • Microwave
  • Refrigerator ...
  • Stove ...
  • Toaster
  • Dining
  • Dining Area
  • seating for 8 people
  • 2 Bathrooms
  • 1 Half Bath
  • Bathroom 1 - toilet , tub , shower
    Bathroom 2 - toilet
    Bathroom 3 - toilet , shower
    Bathroom 4 - outdoor shower
  • 5 Bedrooms, Sleeps 8
  • Bedroom 1 - 1 queen
    Bedroom 2 - 2 twin/ single
    Bedroom 3 - 1 twin/ single
    Bedroom 4 - 1 queen
    Bedroom 5 - 2 twin/ single , Bunk beds
  • Travel crib available
  • Books
  • DVD Player
  • Games ...
  • Stereo ...
  • Television ...
  • Video Library ...
  • Deck / Patio
  • Lanai / Gazebo ...
  • Lawn / Garden ...
  • Outdoor Grill ...
  • Long-term Renters Welcome
  • Minimum Age Limit for Renters ...
  • children welcome ...
  • non smoking only
  • pets not allowed
  • wheelchair inaccessible
Pool / Spa:
  • Heated Pool
  • Private Pool ...
  • autumn foliage
  • bay/sound
  • cinemas
  • festivals
  • forests
  • library
  • playground
  • pond
  • restaurants
  • winery tours
Leisure Activities:
  • antiquing
  • beachcombing
  • bird watching
  • horseback riding
  • outlet shopping
  • paddle boating
  • photography
  • walking
Local Services & Businesses:
  • ATM/bank
  • Babysitter
  • fitness center
  • groceries
  • medical services
Sports & Adventure Activities:
  • cycling
  • deepsea fishing
  • equestrian events
  • fishing
  • golf
  • hiking
  • sailing
  • sound/bay fishing
  • surfing
  • swimming
  • tennis
  • wind-surfing

Partner Offers

You might like these similar properties