expand arrow-rightsvg-balloonsvg-carsvg-dogsvg-fireplacesvg-flat-screensvg-heatersvg-laundry-washing-machinesvg-snowflakesvg-hot-tubsvg-swimming-poolsvg-wheelchairsvg-wifiarrow-right

Montauk, Hither Hills. Pool, Jacuzzi, PoolHouse. Beach Pass. Walk 2 Beach & Town

Montauk, NY, USA
  • House2400 sqft
  • Bedrooms4
  • Sleeps12
  • Bathrooms2
  • Half Baths1
  • Minimum Stay0 - 7 nights

4 Bed, 2.5 Bath with heated pool, jacuzzi & poolhouse in Montauk's Hither Hills




Highlighting our property -- aside from the quick walk to the ocean beach or town -- is a large, heated, salt-water swimming pool, a six person outdoor spa/jacuzzi, and a custom-built, climate controlled, pool house (with sleeper couch for lounging if you need it). All shrouded in glorious privacy. The 20'x40' pool has two shallow ends for enhanced lounging and is a 'sport' design, perfect for volleyball and other pool games.

We are also close to the famous Gurney's Resort, which is walkable in 25 minutes, or just 4 minutes by car. Or take one of our many bikes...

HITHER HILLS properties, like this one, come with restricted access to our own beautiful beach below the bluffs along Old Montauk Highway. You get a parking pass for your car to use at the small parking lots at the beach and a key that opens the barrier chain. ONLY HITHER HILLS residents or renters, NOT other homes in Montauk, have this access. Hence the premium prices...and experience!

With that....Our renovated home has 4 bedrooms, 2.5 baths, and 2 great outdoor showers! The private, climate controlled poolhouse has a sleeper couch for lazy poolside lounging when you need it. Ours is a true beach house, not just a house at the beach...and Hither Hills needs no further explanation for those that know and love Montauk; private beach rights on the most beautiful and least crowded sand in the Hamptons.

Our home is carefully renovated and furnished throughout with classic white everywhere, replete with beachy antiques and curios we've collected over the years, plus a vast collection of books, many related to the ocean, fishing, and nature. Our home also has two entirely separate living rooms with large flat screens, upstairs and down, so cooking shows on one, sports on the other during rainy days. The half acre property is shrouded in trees on all sides yet has a cozy lawn and a very large and private heated pool, jacuzzi/spa, and air conditioned pool house. A truly luxurious property.

The 4 bedrooms have two queens, one full, and one bunk set (plus a trundle in one queen bedroom) and are nicely spaced across the home's two floors, giving true privacy when you need it. The climate controlled pool house has a pullout sofa for lounging during lazy afternoons in private seclusion. That's privacy!

The home has 6 separate zones (incl all bedrooms) for AC/Heat so you'll never suffer during those hot (or cold) days. The pool house also has it's own separate AC and heat.

The large deck is sun drenched all day and leads to a glorious, large and private outdoor shower. The deck's large round table seats 8-10 comfortably for fresh striper from the grill.

Additional amenities include 2 pull-out sleeper couches for guests (one is in the pool house), second refrigerator/freezer for extra storage, a storage shed with 4 great bikes you can use on the many trails around Montauk, plus cable tv, internet, and a wireless networked printer.

Our custom, air conditioned, pool house has it's own large screen TV (total of 4 on the property), vanity sink, sleeper couch, and plenty of seating so you can cool off during those relaxing days in the pool. The adjacent covered gazebo and large in-ground Jacuzzi can present tough decisions!

And as our home is in the eastern part of Hither Hills, you can WALK to the Surfside Inn (not to be confused with Surf Lodge) for dinner or just drinks...since you won't need to drive home!

Also, we have a child safe home...our 2nd floor deck has locking gates at both stairways and our interior stairway has a permanent locking gate as well.

The walk to the beach is about 7 minutes and you have a choice of two entrances. Or drive in 1 minute with the Hither Hills parking pass (we never drive it even with our young children...why?).

Our kitchen has state-of-the-art appliances, including an induction cooktop for you foodies. New washer/dryer as well. Bedrooms have plenty of hanging and storage space plus additional closets throughout the house.

We take safety seriously so you will find several fire extinguishers and smoke detectors throughout, just in case. Automatic outdoor motion sensor lights provide convenience and safety at night...and tip you off when the deer wander through the yard! We also have an AED (aka Defibrillator) in the home...again, just in case.

IMPORTANT: We take pride in the condition and care of our home. While normal wear and tear is expected and anticipated, excessive wear caused by carelessness, overcrowding, or indifference will be noticed and documented on references you will receive from us. Strictly NO SMOKING ON PROPERTY and NO NOISE OUTSIDE AFTER DARK.

Note: If you have events planned (birthdays, anniversaries, bachelor & bachelorette parties, etc.) you must make this known during your initial inquiry. We may or may not agree to accept your booking based on event details, on a case-by-case basis.

For rental periods of three weeks or longer, one-third of rent is due at lease signing and will serve as non-refundable deposit. 2nd third due 90 days prior to move in. Final third, security deposit, and utility deposit due one month prior to move-in. For rental periods shorter than three weeks, one half of rent due at lease signing as non-refundable deposit, 2nd half, security, and utility deposits due 60 days prior to move-in.

Weekly professional cleaning required. Security deposit required. Separate utility deposit required in some cases. Pets may be allowed with additional security on case-by-case basis. Please inquire. All prices quoted include Suffolk Country hotel/motel tax, if applicable.

Thank you for viewing our ad and happy vacationing!


Carter Tyler

Member Since 2012
Response rate:
Response time:
within one day
Calendar last updated:
Apr 17, 2018


    • Internet
    • Pets Welcome
    • Air Conditioning
    • Swimming pool
    • Heater
    • Fireplace
    • Satellite or Cable
    • Kids Welcome
    • Washer & Dryer
    • Hot Tub
    • Parking
    • TV
    • No Smoking


      • 4 Bedrooms, Sleeps 12
      • Bedroom 1
        1 queen
      • Bedroom 2
        1 queen
      • Bedroom 3
        1 queen
      • Bedroom 4
        1 bunk bed
      • Private Pool House with AC & Sleeper Couch
        Private poolhouse with AC has a sleeper sofa for lounging.
      • Queen size Beds (3), Sleep Sofa or Futons (2), Bunk Beds (1)


      • 2 Bathrooms, 1 Half Bath
      • Bathroom 3
        The master bedroom has a 1/2 bath
      • 2 Full baths, 1 half bath, + 2 great outdoor showers!

      Location Type

        • Near The Ocean
          Walk to beautiful and uncrowded Atlantic Ocean beach.


            • Guests provide their own meals


                • Linens Provided
                  House is fully loaded with linens, towels, etc.
                • Air Conditioning
                  Split ductless AC/Heat on both floors. Pool house also climate controlled.
                • Hair Dryer
                • Heating
                  Split ductless AC/Heat on both floors. Pool house also climate controlled.
                • Internet
                  Wi-Fi. Wireless.
                • Iron & Board
                • Clothes Dryer
                  LG, High capacity.
                • Living Room
                • Parking
                  Room for 5 or more cars.
                • Telephone
                  Land line.
                • Towels Provided
                  Many towels provided.
                • Washing Machine
                  Great new machines from LG. High Capacity.
                • Wood Fireplace
                  Great wood fireplace for ambiance any season.


                    • Coffee Maker
                      Keurig machine in 3 rooms, plus a regular coffee maker
                    • Dishes & Utensils
                    • Dishwasher
                    • Kitchen
                      New appliances.
                    • Microwave
                    • Oven
                    • Pantry Items
                      Grill, lots of serveware
                    • Refrigerator
                      Great one!
                    • Stove
                      Induction cooktop
                    • Toaster


                        • Dining
                          Large farm table seats MANY
                        • Dining Area
                        • comfy seating for 10 people


                            • Books
                              Appx. 500 book library in house.
                            • DVD Player
                            • Satellite / Cable
                              On all three TVs
                            • Television
                              3 Large Screens in upstairs LR, downstairs LR, and in Pool House.
                            • Toys
                              Many games in home, including poker table, puzzles, etc.


                                • Bicycles
                                  5 Bikes for your enjoyment in our shed.
                                • Boat
                                  So many choices around Montauk to charter or rent boats!
                                • Deck / Patio
                                  Large deck overlooks property and pool plus separate ground level deck around jacuzzi and privacy trellis
                                • Golf
                                  Montauk Downs golf course is one of the best and most affordable public courses on the east coast.
                                • Lawn / Garden
                                • Outdoor Grill
                                  Large Gas Grill
                                • Tennis
                                  Tennis available at Montauk Downs, just a few minutes drive away.

                                  Pool / Spa

                                    • Heated Pool
                                    • Hot Tub
                                      Jacuzzi tub for up to 8 adjacent to heated swimming pool
                                    • Private Pool
                                      Large 20x40' HEATED sport swimming pool with adjacent 8-person Hot Tub Jacuzzi and cozy poolhouse.


                                        • restaurants

                                          Leisure Activities

                                            • beachcombing
                                            • scenic drives

                                              Local Services & Businesses

                                                • ATM/bank
                                                • groceries
                                                • medical services

                                                  Sports & Adventure Activities

                                                    • pier fishing
                                                    • cycling
                                                    • fishing
                                                    • fly fishing
                                                    • golf
                                                    • hiking
                                                    • mountain biking
                                                    • deepsea fishing
                                                    • roller blading
                                                    • sailing
                                                    • sound/bay fishing
                                                    • surf fishing
                                                    • surfing
                                                    • swimming

                                                      House Rules

                                                      Check-in: 4:30 PM

                                                      Check-out: 11:30 AM

                                                      Cancellation Policy

                                                      Canceled bookings will not receive a refund

                                                      8 Reviews


                                                      Latest reviews

                                                      Relaxing retreat

                                                      Nicole B.

                                                      My family and I stayed here for a long weekend for a wedding and it was our first time in Montauk. We had a wonderful and relaxing time at this home in a quiet neighborhood - a very relaxing retreat for our family. The pool was amazing and the house was clean and very cute. Carter was an excellent home owner and a pleasure to work with. We hope to be back soon!

                                                      Owner's Response:

                                                      Thanks Nicole for taking the time to post your thoughts. We are very happy when our guests have a great experience in the home. You have a wonderful family and we would love to have you back. Thank you again for choosing us!




                                                      Jeffrey P.

                                                      As Carter went to say goodbye after showing us around the property I shook his hand and said "Thanks - we had a great time". We wanted a house where we could kick back and relax and where our kids would have stuff to do and this certainly delivered. The house is beautifully decorated in a way that really celebrates the Montauk culture and history. The fact that the main living area is upstairs and opens out onto to a wraparound deck means that it has a very spacious feel and in our case allowed us to put the kids downstairs where they could have their own holiday den. The pool and gardens are very secluded and there is masses of space if there is a group of you or you have visitors. A great selection of books, games and stuff to keep you occupied if the weather misbehaves.

                                                      Great property - Perfect for groups - Close to beach and town

                                                      daniel c.brooklyn, ny

                                                      I stayed here with a group of 5 couples for three weekends and had a great time. Carter is extremely responsive and went out of his way to make sure we had an enjoyable stay.

                                                      The house itself is well equipped with bikes, beach / yard toys, kitchen equiptment, etc. The interior décor is certainly "beach house," but it's evident that Carter and his family spend significant time their and have produced a very cute house. The pool is warm and the pool house / outdoor shower / hot tub area is very relaxing.

                                                      In terms of location, the house is about 1/8 of a mile to a private ocean beach and a mile from town. The Hither Hills neighborhood is very quaint and a nice area to run / ride bikes.

                                                      Overall I think this is the perfect Montauk house and would recommend highly.

                                                      Great property and owners

                                                      JakeNew york, NY

                                                      Great property in a nice area located very close to the ocean. Backyard is great and the entire property is really great. House is clean and comfortable with lots of room. Perfect for a group of friends or families. Owners were very nice and were as helpful as possible with explaining how to fully utilize the house/property. Great outdoor showers and pool house as well! Would definitely recommend!

                                                      Awesome hither hills house with pool

                                                      Brendan C.

                                                      my family had a great time at house, pool and hot tub were super clean, the pool house was one of a kind, I only stayed three nights, each morning I walked to beach with dog for one hour, the house was spotless and clean, if u like to watch tv 4 cable boxes, my brother in law read a fishing book, I swam in awesome pool great for laps, 6 kids went from pool to hot tub, my father who has many medical issues enjoyed watching his grand kids , when he got tired went to ground level room, plan on definetly coming back to this house, bc

                                                      Amazing Family House - stick the teenagers in the brand new pool house & walk to beach / town!

                                                      JMWestchester County, New York

                                                      Our extended family stayed here in August of 2014. Great property in a beautiful family neighborhood with tons of trees and mature landscaping - so feels very private and secluded. We walked (and sometimes biked) to town daily for coffee and pancakes and then to the beach for evening fires under the stars. Also includes a parking pass to a private beach parking lot. Large and new(er) heated pool with new pool house, Jacuzzi and two outdoor showers. Pool house is awesome with TV and internet - great for the older kids. Also would be perfect for romantic getaways. The house and property has everything you need and the owner is very accessible and dedicated to ensuring you have a wonderful stay. We had an infant and a 3 year old with us (besides 6 year old and 3 teenagers) and all the security gates, etc... are all set-up for you and in perfect working order. Golf, beach, BBQ, pool, hike, run, bike, fish, horseback ride - with amazing restaurants - sunsets at Navy Beach - what's not to love! Enjoy and go with it. Thank again Carter for making our stay excellent!

                                                      Owner's Response:

                                                      Thank You Katy/Ann for taking the time to write a nice review about the property. We like to believe it is a unique and special place, as is Montauk itself, and are pleased to know that your family has created lasting memories here. Glad to know you took advantage of our location near town and the ocean and made use of the pool and pool house. We worked very hard to preserve the natural surroundings and to maintain privacy during the recent renovations, so I'm very glad to hear that you valued this aspect of the property as much as we do. We'd love to have you back and hope you will think of us whenever you plan to be in Montauk. Thank you again!


                                                      Carter and Kay


                                                      Montauk, NY, USA

                                                      The Hither Hills neighborhood is Montauk's premier beach lovers location (ocean beach, not bay), with walking and private parking access to the most beautiful sand in the hamptons only for neighborhood owners and renters.

                                                      Rates & Availability

                                                      Additional information about rental rates

                                                      Cleaning Fee

                                                      Important Notes: - No booking is confirmed until lease agreement is signed AND initial payment has been received and cleared. For fastest and most efficient payment, please pay by Wire, though we accepts checks as well, both personal and bank checks. - A copy of valid driver's licenses or passport is required of all lease signers. - A reference from a prior rental is required of all lease signers. - A refundable security deposit of 3k is not negotiable and is required of all bookings. - A separate Utility Deposit is required covering Pool propane, pool maintenance, electric, and cable/internet. For bookings less than one week, only pool propane is applicable. - Our rental registry number is #16-742 - Suffolk County Hotel Tax, if applicable, is included in the rental price paid.

                                                      8 Reviews
                                                      Exceptional 5/5
                                                      Enter dates for accurate pricing
                                                      For booking assistance, call 888-640-7927

                                                      Property # 430594vb