We were looking for a pet-friendly rental for a few days around a wedding that we were attending in Geneva. A bit of a trek to get up to Geneva, but the cabin was lovely.
Very clean, plenty of space for two people and a dog; there is another bedroom though it might be a little tight for four adults. Would be great for two adults and two kids.
Grocery, beer, and liquor stores are very convenient. Lots of wineries around though we didn't check any out. Also some breweries and distilleries that we hear are quite good.
We stayed in the 'new cabin' and spent a ton of time on the deck. Great views of the lake, slightly obscured by the trees, but sunset-watching was still awesome! We didn't spend too much time by the water, as there were two other families at the other cabins, but we didn't mind.
A few recommendations for the owners:
Add blinds to all the windows. Really helps keep things cool on hot days.
The water pump right outside the bedroom window constantly kicking on every time someone flushes a toilet or turns on the sink is kind of annoying. Maybe it could be moved to the other side of the cabin away from the windows?
A light on the deck would be nice for post-sunset grilling.
We would definitely stay here again if we happen to be in the Seneca Lake area.