Verified Review icon check navigate-up navigate-left navigate-right expand mail svg-lightning svg-24hr svg-house svg-sleeps svg-bedrooms svg-bathrooms svg-stay svg-toilet calendar svg-report-flag pet-dog svg-multiunit
  • Showing 1-50 of 289
Additional fees apply. Taxes may be added.
  View map Map
Wonderful! 4.9/5
(17 reviews)
avg/night
  • 2 BR
  • 1 BA
  • Sleeps 6
Cottage #360888vb
17
Viewed 9 times in the last 48 hours
  • 2 BR
  • 1 BA
  • Sleeps 6
Cottage #597850vb
9
Excellent! 4.7/5
(7 reviews)
avg/night
  • 3 BR
  • 2 BA
  • Sleeps 6
Cottage #702619vb
7
Viewed 15 times in the last 48 hours
avg/night
  • 4 BR
  • 2 BA
  • Sleeps 8
Cottage #4062137
2
Viewed 9 times in the last 48 hours
avg/night
  • 4 BR
  • 2 BA
  • Sleeps 8
Cottage #556885vb
1
Viewed 6 times in the last 48 hours
avg/night
  • 3 BR
  • 2 BA
  • Sleeps 6
Cottage #3525659
4
Viewed 7 times in the last 48 hours
  • 2 BR
  • 2 BA
  • Sleeps 4
Cottage #3808711
avg/night
  • 2 BR
  • 1 BA
  • Sleeps 5
Cottage #576766vb
4
Viewed 23 times in the last 48 hours
Exceptional! 5.0/5
(7 reviews)
avg/night
  • 3 BR
  • 1 BA
  • Sleeps 6
Cottage #830147vb
7
Viewed 19 times in the last 48 hours
Wonderful! 4.9/5
(19 reviews)
avg/night
  • 4 BR
  • 3 BA
  • Sleeps 8
Cottage #989563
19
Viewed 112 times in the last 48 hours
Wonderful! 4.8/5
(11 reviews)
avg/night
  • 3 BR
  • 1 BA
  • 1 HF BA
  • Sleeps 6
Cottage #797161vb
11
Viewed 46 times in the last 48 hours
Wonderful! 4.8/5
(12 reviews)
avg/night
  • 3 BR
  • 1 BA
  • Sleeps 6
Cottage #731486vb
12
Viewed 81 times in the last 48 hours
Exceptional! 5.0/5
(33 reviews)
avg/night
  • 1 BR
  • 1 BA
  • Sleeps 2
Cottage #394407
33
Viewed 34 times in the last 48 hours
Wonderful! 4.8/5
(15 reviews)
avg/night
  • 2 BR
  • 1 BA
  • Sleeps 4
Cottage #694278vb
15
Viewed 42 times in the last 48 hours
Exceptional! 5.0/5
(6 reviews)
avg/night
  • 4 BR
  • 2 BA
  • Sleeps 9
Cottage #4113414
6
Viewed 8 times in the last 48 hours
Exceptional! 5.0/5
(26 reviews)
avg/night
  • 3 BR
  • 2 BA
  • Sleeps 6
Cottage #723865vb
26
Viewed 18 times in the last 48 hours
Wonderful! 4.9/5
(13 reviews)
avg/night
  • 3 BR
  • 2 BA
  • Sleeps 4
Cottage #3953729
13
Viewed 8 times in the last 48 hours
Exceptional! 5.0/5
(10 reviews)
avg/night
  • 1 BR
  • 1 BA
  • Sleeps 2
Cottage #602111vb
10
Viewed 8 times in the last 48 hours
Excellent! 4.7/5
(18 reviews)
avg/night
  • 1 BR
  • 1 BA
  • Sleeps 4
Cottage #192222
18
Viewed 34 times in the last 48 hours
Wonderful! 4.8/5
(19 reviews)
avg/night
  • 3 BR
  • 1 BA
  • Sleeps 5
Cottage #285350vb
19
Viewed 45 times in the last 48 hours
Exceptional! 5.0/5
(13 reviews)
avg/night
  • 2 BR
  • 1 BA
  • 1 HF BA
  • Sleeps 4
Cottage #3481448
13
Viewed 14 times in the last 48 hours
Excellent! 4.3/5
(18 reviews)
avg/night
  • 2 BR
  • 1 BA
  • 1 HF BA
  • Sleeps 6
Cottage #511207vb
18
Viewed 43 times in the last 48 hours
avg/night
  • 2 BR
  • 1 BA
  • Sleeps 4
Cottage #608000vb
2
Viewed 8 times in the last 48 hours
Excellent! 4.4/5
(8 reviews)
avg/night
  • 3 BR
  • 2 BA
  • Sleeps 6
Cottage #997734
8
Viewed 25 times in the last 48 hours
Wonderful! 4.8/5
(9 reviews)
avg/night
  • 3 BR
  • 1 BA
  • Sleeps 6
Cottage #600238vb
9
Wonderful! 4.9/5
(8 reviews)
avg/night
  • 3 BR
  • 1 BA
  • Sleeps 6
Cottage #3862110
8
Viewed 24 times in the last 48 hours
Exceptional! 5.0/5
(10 reviews)
avg/night
  • 2 BR
  • 1 BA
  • Sleeps 4
Cottage #706735vb
10
Viewed 8 times in the last 48 hours
Exceptional! 5.0/5
(10 reviews)
avg/night
  • 2 BR
  • 2 BA
  • Sleeps 4
Cottage #727404vb
10
Viewed 6 times in the last 48 hours
$81
avg/night
  • 3 BR
  • 1 BA
  • 1 HF BA
  • Sleeps 6
Cottage #4113546
1
Viewed 27 times in the last 48 hours
Exceptional! 5.0/5
(19 reviews)
avg/night
  • 2 BR
  • 1 BA
  • Sleeps 4
Cottage #466174vb
19
Viewed 20 times in the last 48 hours
  • 4 BR
  • 2 BA
  • 1 HF BA
  • Sleeps 8
Cottage #281813
Wonderful! 4.9/5
(7 reviews)
avg/night
  • 2 BR
  • 1 BA
  • Sleeps 5
Cottage #872242vb
7
Viewed 29 times in the last 48 hours
Exceptional! 5.0/5
(11 reviews)
avg/night
  • 3 BR
  • 1 BA
  • Sleeps 6
Cottage #191306
11
Viewed 20 times in the last 48 hours
Wonderful! 4.8/5
(6 reviews)
avg/night
  • 2 BR
  • Sleeps 5
Cottage #384097
6
Viewed 17 times in the last 48 hours
avg/night
  • 3 BR
  • 3 BA
  • Sleeps 8
Cottage #572312vb
3
Viewed 17 times in the last 48 hours
  • 3 BR
  • 1 BA
  • 1 HF BA
  • Sleeps 6
Cottage #712237vb
2
Viewed 26 times in the last 48 hours
avg/night
  • 3 BR
  • 1 BA
  • Sleeps 8
Cottage #788996vb
1
Viewed 7 times in the last 48 hours
Exceptional! 5.0/5
(8 reviews)
avg/night
  • 6 BR
  • 1 BA
  • 1 HF BA
  • Sleeps 12
Cottage #885796vb
8
Viewed 30 times in the last 48 hours
Exceptional! 5.0/5
(21 reviews)
avg/night
  • Studio
  • 1 BA
  • Sleeps 2
Cottage #912542
21
Viewed 25 times in the last 48 hours
Wonderful! 4.8/5
(6 reviews)
avg/night
  • 3 BR
  • 1 BA
  • Sleeps 6
Cottage #862727vb
6
Viewed 40 times in the last 48 hours
avg/night
  • 3 BR
  • 1 BA
  • 1 HF BA
  • Sleeps 6
Cottage #825735vb
4
Viewed 17 times in the last 48 hours
  • 2 BR
  • 1 BA
  • Sleeps 4
Cottage #700409vb
6
Wonderful! 4.8/5
(5 reviews)
avg/night
  • 1 BR
  • 1 BA
  • Sleeps 4
Cottage #580862vb
5
Viewed 16 times in the last 48 hours
Exceptional! 5.0/5
(9 reviews)
avg/night
  • 2 BR
  • 1 BA
  • Sleeps 5
Cottage #707484vb
9
Viewed 21 times in the last 48 hours
avg/night
  • 4 BR
  • 1 BA
  • 1 HF BA
  • Sleeps 9
Cottage #678927vb
2
Viewed 21 times in the last 48 hours
avg/night
  • 3 BR
  • 1 BA
  • Sleeps 8
Cottage #163374vb
4
Viewed 28 times in the last 48 hours
Exceptional! 5.0/5
(19 reviews)
avg/night
  • 1 BR
  • 1 BA
  • Sleeps 4
Cottage #242318vb
19
Viewed 19 times in the last 48 hours
Exceptional! 5.0/5
(13 reviews)
avg/night
  • 2 BR
  • 1 BA
  • Sleeps 4
Cottage #412211vb
13
Viewed 17 times in the last 48 hours
avg/night
  • 2 BR
  • 1 BA
  • Sleeps 5
Cottage #749012vb
4
Viewed 8 times in the last 48 hours
avg/night
  • 3 BR
  • 2 BA
  • Sleeps 10
Cottage #896250vb
1
Viewed 50 times in the last 48 hours
  • 1 - 50 of 289

Shelter Island: Cottage Rentals (289)

 

Recent Shelter Island Reviews

Fabulous condition

5 of 5
I would rent from them every time I go to East Hamptons! It was extremely accommodating and great location.
  • Submitted: Nov 7, 2016
  • Stayed: Oct 2016

Another GREAT stay

5 of 5
Great time to be in the Hamptons. Thank you to Naimy for making our stay another top-notch experience.
  • Submitted: Nov 7, 2016
  • Stayed: Oct 2016

Great location on the bay

5 of 5
Susan was an excellent hostess. The location on the bay is wonderful and the house was perfect for us (married couple and a one year old). Would highly recommend.
  • Submitted: Nov 6, 2016
  • Stayed: Nov 2016