Overall, we had a great time at this house. I would definitely recommend it to others. I've separated out some pros and cons below:
+ house itself is very nice and new. It's large, open, and great for hanging out and playing games. The views are also excellent.
+ while small, Athens is a nice town with charming buildings.
+ it was easy to communicate with the owners and everything ran smoothly.
+ plenty of towels and linens.
+ it was cold while we were there, but the porch was nice and would probably be great on a warmer weeekend.
+ the kitchen was not well-organized. Maybe the owner could add some labels to where things go so that it can remain organized.
+ if you want to cook a good meal for a larger group of people, you may want to bring additional kitchen supplies. We had a tough time finding ladles, baking sheets, and spatulas.
+ we saw a mouse inside the house. Isolated incident, but still a mouse.
+ some pieces of furniture were falling apart or a bit grungy.
All in all - great weekend for our group!