Verified Review icon check navigate-up navigate-left navigate-right expand mail svg-lightning svg-24hr svg-house svg-sleeps svg-bedrooms svg-bathrooms svg-stay svg-toilet calendar svg-report-flag pet-dog svg-multiunit
Additional fees apply. Taxes may be added.
  View map Map
    avg/night
    • 2 BR
    • 1 BA
    • Sleeps 5
    Cottage #576766vb
    4
    Viewed 36 times in the last 48 hours
      Wonderful! 4.8/5
      (5 reviews)
      avg/night
      • 4 BR
      • 3 BA
      • Sleeps 8
      House #813764vb
      5
      Viewed 54 times in the last 48 hours
        Exceptional! 5.0/5
        (7 reviews)
        avg/night
        • 3 BR
        • 1 BA
        • Sleeps 6
        Cottage #830147vb
        7
        Viewed 45 times in the last 48 hours
          • 3 BR
          • 2 BA
          • 1 HF BA
          • Sleeps 8
          House #719210vb
          Viewed 25 times in the last 48 hours
            Wonderful! 4.9/5
            (19 reviews)
            avg/night
            • 4 BR
            • 3 BA
            • Sleeps 8
            Cottage #989563
            19
            Viewed 115 times in the last 48 hours
              Wonderful! 4.9/5
              (9 reviews)
              avg/night
              • 3 BR
              • 2 BA
              • Sleeps 8
              House #4095004
              9
              Viewed 48 times in the last 48 hours
                Wonderful! 4.9/5
                (21 reviews)
                avg/night
                • 4 BR
                • 4 BA
                • Sleeps 12
                House #351388
                21
                Viewed 170 times in the last 48 hours
                  Exceptional! 5.0/5
                  (25 reviews)
                  avg/night
                  • 4 BR
                  • 3 BA
                  • Sleeps 8
                  House #323170
                  25
                  Viewed 203 times in the last 48 hours
                    • 3 BR
                    • 2 BA
                    • Sleeps 6
                    House #4352908
                    2
                    Viewed 79 times in the last 48 hours
                      Wonderful! 4.8/5
                      (6 reviews)
                      avg/night
                      • 4 BR
                      • 1 BA
                      • 1 HF BA
                      • Sleeps 7
                      House #707808vb
                      6
                      Viewed 49 times in the last 48 hours
                        Exceptional! 5.0/5
                        (11 reviews)
                        avg/night
                        • 6 BR
                        • 3 BA
                        • Sleeps 12
                        House #330556
                        11
                        Viewed 170 times in the last 48 hours
                          • 1 BR
                          • 1 BA
                          • Sleeps 2
                          Studio #4049919
                          3
                          Viewed 15 times in the last 48 hours
                            Excellent! 4.7/5
                            (33 reviews)
                            avg/night
                            • 1 BR
                            • 1 BA
                            • Sleeps 4
                            Apartment #405769vb
                            33
                            Viewed 39 times in the last 48 hours
                              • 8 BR
                              • 7 BA
                              • 1 HF BA
                              • Sleeps 15
                              House #4159462
                              3
                              Viewed 49 times in the last 48 hours
                                Wonderful! 4.8/5
                                (6 reviews)
                                avg/night
                                • 3 BR
                                • 1 BA
                                • Sleeps 7
                                House #4226268
                                6
                                Viewed 36 times in the last 48 hours
                                  Exceptional! 5.0/5
                                  (28 reviews)
                                  avg/night
                                  • 3 BR
                                  • 2 BA
                                  • Sleeps 6
                                  House #159006
                                  28
                                  Viewed 26 times in the last 48 hours
                                    Exceptional! 5.0/5
                                    (59 reviews)
                                    avg/night
                                    • 2 BR
                                    • 1 BA
                                    • Sleeps 4
                                    Apartment #246865
                                    59
                                    Viewed 49 times in the last 48 hours
                                      Wonderful! 4.9/5
                                      (8 reviews)
                                      avg/night
                                      • 3 BR
                                      • 2 BA
                                      • Sleeps 10
                                      House #3950951
                                      8
                                      Viewed 17 times in the last 48 hours
                                        Wonderful! 4.8/5
                                        (24 reviews)
                                        avg/night
                                        • 2 BR
                                        • 1 BA
                                        • Sleeps 4
                                        House #3789275
                                        24
                                        Viewed 55 times in the last 48 hours
                                          Wonderful! 4.8/5
                                          (30 reviews)
                                          avg/night
                                          • 5 BR
                                          • 3 BA
                                          • Sleeps 10
                                          House #345744
                                          30
                                          Viewed 55 times in the last 48 hours
                                            Exceptional! 5.0/5
                                            (8 reviews)
                                            avg/night
                                            • 3 BR
                                            • 2 BA
                                            • Sleeps 6
                                            House #605998vb
                                            8
                                            Viewed 44 times in the last 48 hours
                                              Exceptional! 5.0/5
                                              (9 reviews)
                                              avg/night
                                              • 5 BR
                                              • 3 BA
                                              • 1 HF BA
                                              • Sleeps 11
                                              House #3961298
                                              9
                                              Viewed 50 times in the last 48 hours
                                                Very Good! 4.1/5
                                                (11 reviews)
                                                avg/night
                                                • 3 BR
                                                • 2 BA
                                                • Sleeps 6
                                                House #364708vb
                                                11
                                                Viewed 93 times in the last 48 hours
                                                  Wonderful! 4.8/5
                                                  (11 reviews)
                                                  avg/night
                                                  • 3 BR
                                                  • 1 BA
                                                  • 1 HF BA
                                                  • Sleeps 6
                                                  Cottage #797161vb
                                                  11
                                                  Viewed 53 times in the last 48 hours
                                                    Exceptional! 5.0/5
                                                    (13 reviews)
                                                    avg/night
                                                    • 4 BR
                                                    • 3 BA
                                                    • Sleeps 8
                                                    House #693288vb
                                                    13
                                                    Viewed 24 times in the last 48 hours
                                                      Wonderful! 4.8/5
                                                      (18 reviews)
                                                      avg/night
                                                      • 2 BR
                                                      • 2 BA
                                                      • Sleeps 7
                                                      House #126214vb
                                                      18
                                                      Viewed 47 times in the last 48 hours
                                                        avg/night
                                                        • 4 BR
                                                        • 1 BA
                                                        • 1 HF BA
                                                        • Sleeps 10
                                                        House #915158
                                                        2
                                                        Viewed 17 times in the last 48 hours
                                                          Wonderful! 4.9/5
                                                          (12 reviews)
                                                          avg/night
                                                          • 5 BR
                                                          • 3 BA
                                                          • 1 HF BA
                                                          • Sleeps 12
                                                          House #773702vb
                                                          12
                                                          Viewed 106 times in the last 48 hours
                                                            Wonderful! 4.8/5
                                                            (12 reviews)
                                                            avg/night
                                                            • 3 BR
                                                            • 1 BA
                                                            • Sleeps 6
                                                            Cottage #731486vb
                                                            12
                                                            Viewed 77 times in the last 48 hours
                                                              Exceptional! 5.0/5
                                                              (9 reviews)
                                                              avg/night
                                                              • 5 BR
                                                              • 5 BA
                                                              • Sleeps 12
                                                              House #4178853
                                                              9
                                                              Viewed 39 times in the last 48 hours
                                                                Wonderful! 4.8/5
                                                                (26 reviews)
                                                                avg/night
                                                                • 4 BR
                                                                • 3 BA
                                                                • Sleeps 8
                                                                House #428409vb
                                                                26
                                                                Viewed 31 times in the last 48 hours
                                                                  Exceptional! 5.0/5
                                                                  (18 reviews)
                                                                  avg/night
                                                                  • 4 BR
                                                                  • 2 BA
                                                                  • Sleeps 8
                                                                  House #555509vb
                                                                  18
                                                                  Viewed 120 times in the last 48 hours
                                                                    • 4 BR
                                                                    • 3 BA
                                                                    • 1 HF BA
                                                                    • Sleeps 10
                                                                    House #732010vb
                                                                    4
                                                                    Viewed 54 times in the last 48 hours
                                                                      Exceptional! 5.0/5
                                                                      (20 reviews)
                                                                      avg/night
                                                                      • 3 BR
                                                                      • 2 BA
                                                                      • 1 HF BA
                                                                      • Sleeps 6
                                                                      House #902109
                                                                      20
                                                                      Viewed 77 times in the last 48 hours
                                                                        Wonderful! 4.9/5
                                                                        (10 reviews)
                                                                        avg/night
                                                                        • 3 BR
                                                                        • 2 BA
                                                                        • Sleeps 6
                                                                        House #724861vb
                                                                        10
                                                                        Viewed 77 times in the last 48 hours
                                                                          Exceptional! 5.0/5
                                                                          (33 reviews)
                                                                          avg/night
                                                                          • 1 BR
                                                                          • 1 BA
                                                                          • Sleeps 2
                                                                          Cottage #394407
                                                                          33
                                                                          Viewed 43 times in the last 48 hours
                                                                            Wonderful! 4.9/5
                                                                            (35 reviews)
                                                                            avg/night
                                                                            • 2 BR
                                                                            • 1 BA
                                                                            • 1 HF BA
                                                                            • Sleeps 6
                                                                            Apartment #563575vb
                                                                            35
                                                                            Viewed 35 times in the last 48 hours
                                                                              Wonderful! 4.8/5
                                                                              (15 reviews)
                                                                              avg/night
                                                                              • 2 BR
                                                                              • 1 BA
                                                                              • Sleeps 4
                                                                              Cottage #694278vb
                                                                              15
                                                                              Viewed 54 times in the last 48 hours
                                                                                Exceptional! 5.0/5
                                                                                (8 reviews)
                                                                                avg/night
                                                                                • 4 BR
                                                                                • 2 BA
                                                                                • Sleeps 10
                                                                                House #575273vb
                                                                                8
                                                                                Viewed 12 times in the last 48 hours
                                                                                  Exceptional! 5.0/5
                                                                                  (6 reviews)
                                                                                  avg/night
                                                                                  • 4 BR
                                                                                  • 3 BA
                                                                                  • Sleeps 14
                                                                                  House #821199vb
                                                                                  6
                                                                                  Viewed 40 times in the last 48 hours
                                                                                    Exceptional! 5.0/5
                                                                                    (8 reviews)
                                                                                    avg/night
                                                                                    • 4 BR
                                                                                    • 2 BA
                                                                                    • Sleeps 9
                                                                                    House #4244756
                                                                                    8
                                                                                    Viewed 12 times in the last 48 hours
                                                                                      Exceptional! 5.0/5
                                                                                      (5 reviews)
                                                                                      avg/night
                                                                                      • 4 BR
                                                                                      • 4 BA
                                                                                      • Sleeps 12
                                                                                      House #602286vb
                                                                                      5
                                                                                      Viewed 76 times in the last 48 hours
                                                                                        • 3 BR
                                                                                        • 3 BA
                                                                                        • Sleeps 8
                                                                                        House #4179019
                                                                                        3
                                                                                        Viewed 43 times in the last 48 hours
                                                                                          Excellent! 4.7/5
                                                                                          (12 reviews)
                                                                                          avg/night
                                                                                          • 3 BR
                                                                                          • 2 BA
                                                                                          • Sleeps 6
                                                                                          Bungalow #607456vb
                                                                                          12
                                                                                          Viewed 96 times in the last 48 hours
                                                                                            • 4 BR
                                                                                            • 3 BA
                                                                                            • Sleeps 10
                                                                                            House #640233vb
                                                                                            3
                                                                                            Viewed 46 times in the last 48 hours
                                                                                              • 4 BR
                                                                                              • 3 BA
                                                                                              • Sleeps 10
                                                                                              House #725998vb
                                                                                              2
                                                                                              Viewed 5 times in the last 48 hours
                                                                                                Wonderful! 4.9/5
                                                                                                (12 reviews)
                                                                                                avg/night
                                                                                                • 4 BR
                                                                                                • 2 BA
                                                                                                • Sleeps 8
                                                                                                House #232078
                                                                                                12
                                                                                                Viewed 56 times in the last 48 hours
                                                                                                  Excellent! 4.7/5
                                                                                                  (11 reviews)
                                                                                                  avg/night
                                                                                                  • 2 BR
                                                                                                  • 1 BA
                                                                                                  • Sleeps 6
                                                                                                  House #234542vb
                                                                                                  11
                                                                                                  Viewed 47 times in the last 48 hours
                                                                                                    Wonderful! 4.8/5
                                                                                                    (9 reviews)
                                                                                                    avg/night
                                                                                                    • 1 BR
                                                                                                    • 1 BA
                                                                                                    • Sleeps 2
                                                                                                    Studio #807350vb
                                                                                                    9
                                                                                                    Viewed 43 times in the last 48 hours
                                                                                                      • 3 BR
                                                                                                      • 2 BA
                                                                                                      • Sleeps 9
                                                                                                      House #840124vb
                                                                                                      3
                                                                                                      • 101 - 150 of 300+

                                                                                                      Shelter Island: Houses, Cottages & More | Page 3 (300+)

                                                                                                       

                                                                                                      Recent Shelter Island Reviews

                                                                                                      Fantastic property close to town with lots of room.

                                                                                                      5 of 5
                                                                                                      We stayed at this house during the Christmas/New Years week so I can't necessarily speak to how it would play in the summer; however, its location close to town and some of EH's best restaurants can't really be beat. It has a large fully appointed kitchen, four good-sized bedrooms--two with their en suite baths--a working fireplace and a large TV/living room (though the latter room doesn't have a working fireplace). The yard is huge--almost two acres which our city dog absolutely loved. The house was clean and well-maintained and the owner is a fantastic guy and very accessible (though we never needed to contact him during our stay because everything was in such great shape--lots of towels, hotel-like bathroom amenities, etc). The only thing I would note is that the house is right on a very busy street (Cedar Street) so vigilance is in order for kids and dogs (though the fenced-in yard is so huge there should be no reason for that to become much of an issue). I would definitely recommend this house and would, in fact, like to stay there again--next time in the summer!
                                                                                                      • Submitted: Jan 9, 2017
                                                                                                      • Stayed: Dec 2016

                                                                                                      Perfect getaway, anytime of year

                                                                                                      5 of 5
                                                                                                      This place was amazing! It was modern, beautiful, spacious, cozy, and clean! We loved it! The only feedback we have is there was a problem with the speaker system so watching tv/movies/ music was an issue which made it tough during the snowstorm. And it would have helped to have found a shovel in the closet to shovel ourselves out of the parking spot. Everything else was great!
                                                                                                      • Submitted: Jan 8, 2017
                                                                                                      • Stayed: Jan 2017

                                                                                                      Holiday weekend perfection!

                                                                                                      5 of 5
                                                                                                      My family and I stayed at Taran's house for New Years Eve weekend. It exceeded all of our expectations! My family and I travel a lot and have stayed in many rental properties and there is always something that disappoints. This house does NOT disappoint. The kitchen is the real gem of this house in the off season. It's modern and beautiful and perfect for cooking and gathering. It was fully stocked with every chef's cooking utensil, appliance, spice and dish ware you could ever need. The open layout of the rest of the downstairs and abundance of natural light made it the perfect place to hang out with our family. The house was immaculate. The bedrooms were all comfortable and quiet. I can only imagine how nice this house is during the summer with the pool and hot tub right outside the french doors! It's also minutes from downtown Sag Harbor which makes it extremely convenient. In addition, Taran was extremely communicative and answered questions we had prior to our visit and even during our stay. I highly recommend this property and hope we have the opportunity to stay here again.! Rebekah
                                                                                                      • Submitted: Jan 6, 2017
                                                                                                      • Stayed: Dec 2016