I rented Koi Palms for my honeymoon and it was perfect. It is located perfectly between the beach and town stores. With a max walking distance of just under 1 mile. If you want to snorkel you can walk 2 miles to Lanikai beach.
The property feels very private with a private entrance and lots of plants to screen you from the main house. When you walk through the private gate the bbq and shed with the beach stuff are to the left and the lanai (the patio and front door) is to the right. Through the front door the kitchen is directly in front of you with the couch, bathroom, and bed room to the right in that order. One bedroom wall is shared with the house so you can hear the people in the main house briefly talking or shuffling things around. There was little to none main house noise. It did not keep me from enjoying my honeymoon.
It was very clean and cozy. They had a welcome basket for us on the first day with fruit, coffee, and flowers. I would definitely comeback here again.