Properties in Church Bay average 4.8 out of 5 stars.
1 - 50 of 202
Additional fees apply.Taxes may be added.

All the vacation rentals available direct from owner in Church Bay

Recent Church Bay Reviews

  • Beautiful immaculate, spacious cottage, central location
    5 of 5

    We loved this beautiful, well maintained, lovely & fully equipped, well stocked cottage. Appliances were great, very convenient location as it was close to ferries and grocery store. Pat and Naomi were so warm and accommodating with information and suggestions. Close to the south shore beaches which was a great plus. Perfect for a family or 2 couples. Loved watching the nightly sunset over the harbour. We’re sure to return someday!

    Stayed: Jun 2019
  • Wonderful!
    5 of 5

    Location, location, location! Wendell’s property is adjacent to the Fairmont Southampton resort - which means you can use all the resort facilities, but you have access to a better private beach steps from your room. Wendell could not have been more accommodating - the recommendations be provided were extremely helpful. If you want to explore beyond the private beach, I would skip Horseshoe Bay and go start to Warwick (unless you like throngs of tourists). Also, we ate at Henry IIIV twice and had lunch from their small store - excellent food and scenery and cheaper than the Fairmont. If you explore the Island, skip Tobacco Bay and head straight to St. Catherine’s and the beach in front of Blackbirds Hideout restaurant - great snorkeling and food too! This Airbnb is the best location on the island! Thanks for having us!

    Stayed: May 2019