We loved Brook Cottage Too! Very close to downtown and Comeau park, everything walkable. Extremely clean and very comfy bed. Lots of grass outside for our dogs that were traveling with us. We all enjoyed hiking Comeau park, which was literally in the backyard of the cottage. We will definitely be back!
My boyfriend and I stayed at Herb Cottage for a few days and it was an awesome spot. The cottage is quaint, cozy and tidy, and the hosts were extremely hospitable. The wood burning stove is the best part in our opinion! Would recommend this place for a nice getaway to a small, peaceful town in upstate NY.