Verified Review icon check navigate-up navigate-left navigate-right expand mail svg-lightning svg-24hr svg-house svg-sleeps svg-bedrooms svg-bathrooms svg-stay svg-toilet calendar svg-report-flag pet-dog svg-multiunit Default Owner Icon heart-filled

Pretty Picky Properties

  • Established in 2003
  • Hours: 8am-8pm EST phone, 24/7 email

There are a lot of places to rent for a summer vacation on the Lower Cape. There are only a few Pretty Picky Properties. Most are directly on or very near the beach. Our homeowners love their properties, fastidiously maintain them, and expect guests to treat them accordingly. Our guests demand a prime location and a vacation experience that far exceeds the typical Cape summer rental. When you spend a good amount of money for a perfect summer vacation, you want to be sure before you commit. That's why we take the time to carefully and completely answer all your questions by phone or email. If you can visit the Cape in advance, we'll be happy to show you one or more properties you're considering. Most guests are also comforted to know that Pretty Picky also has a property management division, Monomoy Property Services. Most unforeseen property issues can be resolved quickly with our ready access to maintenance resources. We look forward to helping you plan your ideal Cape Cod vacation!

Our philosophy

Our mission is to provide discriminating vacationers, typically families with children, with the best Cape Cod vacation experience ever!


Besides the usual rental broker services, we offer a value added rental service experience. For example, in most cases, we personally meet and greet arriving rental guests at the property, taking the time to provide a brief orientation and review any unusual property features and beach access, as well as owner-approved guidelines. We also answer any guest questions and make suggestions resulting in a more enjoyable stay.

Total Properties: 0
Cancel Clear Filters Apply Filters
More Filters

Price Per Night

$ $



Booking Options

Location Type

Even More Filters


Managed By

Clear Filters
Use filters to narrow your search results!
There are no results which match your criteria. Try refining your search parameters.