Shelter Island, NY, USA

We found 2,728 vacation rentals — enter your dates for availability

Shelter Island, NY, USA

Shelter Island vacation rentals

Explore the Beachside Setting in Shelter Island

The ocean, beaches and island views are a perfect backdrop to your vacation home in Shelter Island. Renowned for its aquarium, wineries and boating, this city welcomes all visitors. There are plenty of chances to soak up some sunshine at Wades Beach, Menhadden Lane Beach and Shell Beach. If you want to stay someplace a bit more spacious, consider a vacation rental. Many rental homes come with Internet access, air conditioning and a kitchen.