My wife and I just stayed 5 nights here for our honeymoon. I've stayed in amazing hotels and properties all over the world and this may have topped them all. The kitchen, furniture, bathrooms, pool, washer/dryer, landscaping are all top notch and very well maintained.
The views of the ocean from the patio, pool and living room are stunning. We really didn't want to leave any of the nights. The sounds of the jungle are very soothing and with all the lights out at night the stars pop out of the sky. The TV has 300 movies on a hard drive to watch, which was nice for lazy afternoons. Good quality iPOD dock as well, was great to have loud music - with no neighbors anywhere around it was fun to be loud.
The place is really secluded, you can't see any other properties. The dirt road to the property is easy (probably don't need 4x4 but better safe than sorry). It's only 5 minutes to get down to the main paved road. From there - you are right at Dominicalito Beach and it's only another 5 minutes to Dominical Beach. Plenty of cool restaurants and places to get groceries nearby. Day trip to Manuel Antonio, hike to an AMAZING waterfall, surf everyday - then back to the palace everything.
Neil is a class act, and a really cool guy. I love to meet people that take great pride in what they do. He told us everything we needed to know - including a great recommendation on where to buy fresh fish to cook (yum) and where to go to eat if we didn't want to cook. Directions were spot on and very easy to follow.
I'll return to Dominical and will rent this place from Neil again. Would recommend it to anyone.