La Jolla Caribe was pretty much perfect for my family of nine. There's enough room to spread out plus a nice living room where we could hang out together. The kitchen had everything we needed and was far better than in most rentals. We had a toddler with us so having a hot tub and no pool was good - plus why would you want a pool when there are many wonderful beaches close at hand?
The location is close to everything (OK, maybe everything is close to everything on St. John) but it was easy to get to town for shopping and the beaches for swimming. You absolutely must have a high clearance, 4 wheel drive vehicle since the road is a goat path, especially downhill to Cinnamon Bay.
It's hard to overstate the view. For the most part you are looking at undeveloped parkland or the sea or distant islands. You really are king of the mountain with a vast kingdom below.
The bedrooms were bright and cheerful and there were some complaints about biting insects but that was probably the only griping I heard all week. Everything was clean and well maintained and the management company was always helpful.
Anyone able to spend a week at this house (and this island) should be grateful for their good fortune in life.