My wife, 2-yr-old daughter and I rented the house for a 3-day weekend and were very happy with the space and amenities, all of which were exactly as advertised. The house has a very cozy feel to it and is very well maintained. The location is nice and secluded and offers a nice break from city noise, if you happen to be coming from NYC or another urban area.
The night we got there it was about 25 degrees outside and the house was quite chilly but warmed up very nicely within a few hours after we turned on the heat. Having two bathrooms was a nice feature as well. We highly recommend Jake's Tavern (about 5 or 10 minutes north by car) for great bar food in a family-friendly atmosphere (you'll be very happy here if you like wings) - our daughter has a peanut allergy and Jake's uses no nut oils or nuts in any of their food.
Proximity to excellent state parks is great - plenty of great hiking nearby. Can only imagine how beautiful it must be in the winter.
Payment and communication with Theresa (the owner) was easy and clear - no surprises, which is a good thing in this regard.
Highly recommended all around. Thanks, Theresa!