We recently stayed in the this home on Put In Bay. We were VERY pleasantly surprised by the comfort and roominess of the home. The Home was clean, and had everything we needed for our stay. We spent the evenings on the deck, enjoying the wines we purchased from the Island winery, and had a great time talking with the neighbors. Even the owner, John, contacted us to make sure everything was up to par, which we felt was a great personal touch.
The development is nice, with a fun pool nearby and is withing walking distance to the State park and, if your up to a little challenge (and don't get sidetracked by the winery) to town. We took our car across, but used the taxi service most of the time, because it's so convenient and then we could all enjoy ourselves at the bars.
We have stayed on Put In Bay several times, in the hotels, B&B's and other homes. This was, in our opinion, the best deal cost wise and space wise. We are already talking about going back next year, and will definately look to this home for our accommedations!