I really enjoyed my stay here. Nancy was really helpful in showing me around and really friendly! For me, this was a great location - I brought my bike and took a ride on the Olentangy trail to the Park of Roses, I was able to visit friends in Clintonville by foot, and easily picked up the 4B bus to downtown for the Arts Festival. It's also very easy to get onto the highway from there.
Also right up the street is the Crest gastropub, Studio 35 bar and theater and if you're into beer, Savor Growl which has a great selection and fills growlers. Also on High street just north of Arcadia is Growl!, which also does tastings and growler fills. On 4th street, I'd recommend Seventh Son Brewery, too (great beer with a food truck parked).
Overall, a very good experience!