We rented this house to attend a wedding in the area, and it was only a 2 hour drive from NYC. The house is just as nice in person as it looks in the pictures. It is large and has a complete wrap around deck. The kitchen and outdoor grill are fantastic and was well stocked with excellent cookware and pantry basics.
The house is brand new and kept in great condition. Lot is very large, private and completely quiet. Owner was very responsive. Would definitely rent from again.
One minor disappointment was that the house does not have internet (it does have satellite TV). The owner let us know this before checkin and we were able to bring a Mi-Fi for internet (Verizon service is excellent and AT&T works but is spotty in places).