Unless I get some ridiculous deal, I will never stay in a New York hotel again. That being said:
Pros: First off, Yuriy is great. He answered all my questions promptly. The place was spotless. The bed was comfy, and my friend said the pull-out bed was great. The neighborhood is fantastic--not a tourist trap! Lots of awesome bars, restaurants and shops. The West 4th subway station is literally around the corner and Washington Square Park is a short walk away.
Cons: (These are just me being picky.) The Apple TV is great, but I'm a news junkie and would've loved to have some access to local channels. But we were only there to sleep so it didn't matter. Had to buy some toilet paper, but CVS is super close so no biggie.
Loved it! Would stay again. :)