Price Per Week

$ $

Sleeps

Bedrooms

Bathrooms

Booking Options

Property Type

Barns
Cottages
Estates
Farmhouses
Homes
Apartments
Boats
Bungalows
Cabins
Castles
Chalets
Condos
Hotels
Lodges
Studios
Townhomes
Villas
Yachts

Location Type

Even More Filters

Features

Managed By

Cancel Clear Filters Apply Filters
Use filters to narrow your search results!

Shelter Island Vacation Rentals with Fireplace(67)

67 Results
7 night minimum stay
  • 5 BR,
  • 3 BA,
  • Sleeps 10
    (9)
    14 night minimum stay
    • 6 BR,
    • 4 BA,
    • 2 HF BA,
    • Sleeps 12
      7 night minimum stay
      • 3 BR,
      • 2 BA,
      • Sleeps 6
        (3)
        7 night minimum stay
        • 3 BR,
        • 2 BA,
        • 1 HF BA,
        • Sleeps 4
          2 Reviews
          Book it Now!
          • 5 BR,
          • 3 BA,
          • Sleeps 10
            Book it Now!
            7 night minimum stay
            • 6 BR,
            • 4 BA,
            • Sleeps 14
              2 Reviews
              Book it Now!
              3 - 14 night minimum stay
              • 4 BR,
              • 4 BA,
              • 1 HF BA,
              • Sleeps 10
                Book it Now!
                14 - 30 night minimum stay
                • 3 BR,
                • 2 BA,
                • Sleeps 8
                  Book it Now!
                  2 - 3 night minimum stay
                  • 6 BR,
                  • 7 BA,
                  • Sleeps 14
                    (7)
                    30 night minimum stay
                    • 2 BR,
                    • 2 BA,
                    • Sleeps 6
                      2 Reviews
                      2 - 9 night minimum stay
                      • 4 BR,
                      • 3 BA,
                      • 2 HF BA,
                      • Sleeps 12
                        (5)
                        4 - 14 night minimum stay
                        • 4 BR,
                        • 3 BA,
                        • Sleeps 7
                          (4)
                          14 night minimum stay
                          • 3 BR,
                          • 3 BA,
                          • Sleeps 7
                            (4)
                            $3,500 - $3,850
                            per week
                            Book it Now!
                            14 - 30 night minimum stay
                            • 4 BR,
                            • 3 BA,
                            • Sleeps 8
                              Book it Now!
                              3 night minimum stay
                              • 3 BR,
                              • 2 BA,
                              • 1 HF BA,
                              • Sleeps 8
                                1 Review
                                Book it Now!
                                2 night minimum stay
                                • 4 BR,
                                • 2 BA,
                                • 1 HF BA,
                                • Sleeps 8
                                  2 Reviews
                                  Book it Now!
                                  6 - 28 night minimum stay
                                  • 3 BR,
                                  • 2 BA,
                                  • Sleeps 8
                                    1 Review
                                    7 - 30 night minimum stay
                                    • 3 BR,
                                    • 2 BA,
                                    • Sleeps 6
                                      2 Reviews
                                      3 - 14 night minimum stay
                                      • 3 BR,
                                      • 2 BA,
                                      • 1 HF BA,
                                      • Sleeps 6
                                        (7)
                                        3 - 30 night minimum stay
                                        • 3 BR,
                                        • 2 BA,
                                        • Sleeps 6
                                          (3)
                                          27 - 30 night minimum stay
                                          • 4 BR,
                                          • 3 BA,
                                          • Sleeps 8
                                            3 night minimum stay
                                            • 3 BR,
                                            • 3 BA,
                                            • Sleeps 6
                                              3 - 31 night minimum stay
                                              • 4 BR,
                                              • 3 BA,
                                              • Sleeps 9
                                                1 Review
                                                7 - 30 night minimum stay
                                                • 5 BR,
                                                • 3 BA,
                                                • 1 HF BA,
                                                • Sleeps 10
                                                  2 - 7 night minimum stay
                                                  • 2 BR,
                                                  • 1 BA,
                                                  • 1 HF BA,
                                                  • Sleeps 6
                                                    7 night minimum stay
                                                    • 3 BR,
                                                    • 3 BA,
                                                    • Sleeps 6
                                                      7 night minimum stay
                                                      • 3 BR,
                                                      • 3 BA,
                                                      • Sleeps 8
                                                        3 - 7 night minimum stay
                                                        • 5 BR,
                                                        • 4 BA,
                                                        • Sleeps 10
                                                          (4)
                                                          • 3 BR,
                                                          • 1 BA,
                                                          • 1 HF BA,
                                                          • Sleeps 6
                                                            1 Review
                                                            38 more choices from the HomeAway Network
                                                            3 night minimum stay
                                                            • 2 BR,
                                                            • 2 BA,
                                                            • 1 HF BA,
                                                            • Sleeps 4
                                                              (10)
                                                              Advertisement
                                                               

                                                              Recent Shelter Island Reviews

                                                              Charming Cottage and Terrific Owners

                                                              5 of 5
                                                              We had a wonderful multi-week stay here. The house is as charming as advertised. We swam off the dock every day. Also kept my 20' sailboat at the dock and had great fun sailing in Gardner's bay. Topping it all off, the owners were a delight to deal with as we settled in and got our bearings. If you're considering this property give it a go, you'll be glad you did!
                                                              • Submitted: Aug 24, 2014
                                                              • Stayed: Jun 2014

                                                              Fantastic, Family Friendly, Well-Equipped Dream

                                                              5 of 5
                                                              This house was wonderful. The kitchen was fully equipped with spices, paper goods, sunscreen, bug spray -- everything you need but don't necessarily want to pack. The pool and hot tub were the focal attraction for our clan, but the screened in porch and ample supply of board games were very much appreciated. My girls loved the family of deer who visited twice daily, and the close proximity to town and beaches was also a hit. The owners are incredibly responsive and helpful. I cannot say enough good things about this place! I would only add: the Clam Chowder at SALT is the best on the island!
                                                              • Submitted: Aug 18, 2014
                                                              • Stayed: Aug 2014

                                                              Fantastic holiday in this house!

                                                              5 of 5
                                                              John the owner was wonderfully helpful from start to finish with our holiday to Shelter Island. He was unfazed that we were going to be five mommies and babies for the week and was on hand to answer questions all the time. The garden is beautiful, the rooms all airy and clean (excepting a great room in the basement without light which was great for babies to sleep in!) and from here we were able to do long strolls to Sunset Beach and to the spit on the south of the island. All round fabulous- highly recommended.
                                                              • Submitted: Jun 30, 2014
                                                              • Stayed: May 2014