Our group had a wonderful time at Lake Muskoday. The house was beautiful, clean and spacious, with great amenities. We had a blast with the boats out on the lake during the day, and sitting by the fire pit at night. We pretty much just lived on the dock the entire time.
The location is great — you really feel away from it all. BUT: Get all your groceries and necessities before the trip. We didn't plan that so well, and ended up making (somewhat long) trips to town for additional items.