My partner and I spent a week at Garibaldi's cabin over Valentine's Day, and couldn't have asked for a better stay. The cabin is wonderfully decorated, full of the conveniences you're looking for (hello, dishwasher!) and the thoughtful touches that make it welcoming (chocolate, flowers, and wine).
Garibaldi has thought of everything for your arrival, including having the lights and music on and a fire ready to be lit. It was also the most beautifully made bed I've seen anywhere except for a magazine article, so definite bonus points for that.
Communication before, during, and after our vacation was easy, and responses prompt. (Garibaldi also forwarded information before our rental, which was helpful.) The cabin was spotless, and you could still see the vacuum tracks on the furniture. The kitchen has had small changes since these photos, which have opened it up and made it brighter, and the appliances are up-to-date and as spotless as the rest of the cabin.
The location was secluded enough that you felt like you were alone in the world (if that's what you're looking for), but close enough that you can go for lunch just 10 minutes away (we had great meals at the Phoenicia Diner). It was very cold during our stay, and Garibaldi had plenty of wood chopped and ready for use in the woodstove.
We would change nothing about our stay, except perhaps making it longer! I cannot recommend this cabin, and this owner, highly enough. You will not be disappointed.