We rented both the Nest and the Nook with my parents during the summer, and had a wonderful experience. We planned to do several activities in the area but ended up grilling delicious food and spending most of our time by the pool. Was a truly memorable and restful experience. Everything was very clean and had all the things you would need. No bugs or any issues. Owners are friendly & gracious and allow you to enjoy your space.( I've been to places where owners are way too in your face and want to join you in activities...) Location is very convenient for non drivers, bus from NYC drops you off nearby and is within walking distance. Local shops are abound, love Bread Alone. There is a relatively close natural foods supermarket in town but we ended up opting to drive to the regular supermarket 10 min away.
All in all a very peaceful place, we will definitely be looking to rent again next summer!