We stayed at the Loft Lookout for three night. It was exactly as described and was very comfortable and clean. The two bedrooms were large and had comfy beds, too. It was in walking distance of almost everything in Gardiner and made for a perfect base for exploring the Upper Loop of Yellowstone. The rental process and checking in went very smoothly, but we didn't get to personally meet Gina. Our favorite restaurant was The Lighthouse, about 4-5 miles from the Loft Lookout. The Cowboy Grill/Restaurant below us was quiet by 10:00 PM and didn't open for breakfast, so noise was not an issue at all. We enjoyed our stay very much.