We've been coming to the Vineyard every summer for 10 years and this was one of the nicest homes we've stayed in! The location is perfect - a 5 minute walk to downtown Edgartown. The house, while an antique, is clean, well furnished and updated. We arrived to find a wonderful and complete guide to the house and the island, as well as a personal note and locally baked cookies! It was a very nice and thoughtful touch. The fenced backyard and patio was a perfect place to relax with coffee in the morning before starting our day.
We did have two very small issues during our stay, and the owner and property manager addressed them immediately. They were apologetic and as unobtrusive as possible. I would definitely recommend staying here while enjoying all the Vineyard has to offer!