We just returned from a terrific two week stay at Liz and Paul's house in Edgartown. We are a family of 5 (three teenagers) and the house was ideal for us. It is very nicely decorated, extremely well kept, and had lots of room inside. The house has a number of decks, including a second-story one that was our favorite following a day at the beach. There was another deck that had a great set-up for outdoor dining and a family size hot tub which was a nice way to end the day.
The location of the house was about 1.5 miles from Edgartown Center. The neighborhood was extremely green and therefore felt very private as you were surrounded by trees on all sides. My wife, kids and I would all highly recommend this lovely property for a relaxing stay on this beautiful island.