It's a 5 because it couldn't be any better...the property was as described and charming. My husband and I spent a few days there and for us, the location was ideal...places to walk and easy places to get to by car (remember this was off-season). We walked the boardwalk some and got to see the kite contest - interesting and colorful. Took a boat tour to see the ponies...the business was "Captain Bob," I think...in any event, the only tour business with "Captain" in the name - I wish I could remember the name of the restaurants we tried...but hard to find a bad crab cake. Definitely would go back again and refer this location to friends.