My friends and I had a great stay at Jeff's house in Rangeley. Every need was taken care of. The kitchen is full of supplies, including three coffee makers (excellent when you're hosting 13 guys who are NOT morning people). There were plenty of linens. It snowed the night before we had to leave, but there were snow shovels handy, and the roads in Rangeley are very well maintained.
One thing for people coming from Boston or other points south: Your GPS will advise you to take Route 17. Do not do this; the road is in terrible condition. Route 4, while longer, is in much better condition and will be faster to drive.
We look forward to renting again next year!