I chose Todi (for 4 adults) simply because George's house had a garden & view of the valley. What a great choice it turned out to be! There are not many tourists in Todi (unlike other towns we visited) but plenty of restaurants and great clothing shops. We particularly enjoyed the brilliant food at Antica Osteria della Valle.
The house is quaint and delightful, very clean and well maintained - spread over 4 levels - and well equipped with plenty of cutlery, crockery, serving platters,pots, pans etc. Every bedroom has a view of the valley, as does the living room. It was nice that people had not thrown out their left-over olive oil, balsamic, tea bags, washing detergent etc, and we did the same for the next tenants. There were travel guides a'plenty on Todi and Umbria, and a well-stacked library of books and magazines. We had every meal possible in the garden at the table under the massive fig tree (unfortunately the figs weren't quite ripe). The view of the valley is breathtaking and we spent many hours just sitting and absorbing it, with the odd glass of vino, of course! A hot air balloon competition was on, and we delighted in watching them from the little balcony off the bathroom/laundry as they floated up from the misty valley early in the morning .
We organised a cooking class in the house one night - loads of fun and we made every dish from scratch and then sat down to a feast. At George's suggestion, we hired a car from a local dealer. It was there waiting for us in the private car park just below the house when we arrived. Too easy! We did day trips to other towns, but also had "lay days" exploring Todi and enjoying the ambience of the house and our lovely view. George rang several times to check that things were going well. We were intrigued with the history of the house and wished we could have read about it and seen pictures of what it once was like.
Would I recommend this house to others? Most definitely.