My adult children, their significant others, my S.O. and I spent a wonderful week at the thoughtfully designed Paia Beach House. It's just as described -- clean and well maintained, three bedrooms with very comfortable beds and high quality linens, a spacious great room with a well-appointed kitchen (even the knives were sharp), tasteful art from the Paia Contemporary Art Gallery, lots of stuff for the beach (boogie, surf, and sail boards, beach chairs, snorkels, face masks, fins, etc.), and outdoor showers. It really could not have been any better.
Although the house faces the beach, it is right off the main drag going through Paia so it's an easy walk to everything in town. We especially loved Mana Foods (if you can't find it there, you don't need it) and Ono Gelato.
Francisco was gracious and a pleasure to work with as well. The only advice I have for future guests is if you rent two cars, insist that one be an economy or compact size (no larger than a Ford Focus) because otherwise parking can be quite challenging.
We look forward to returning!