We had an amazing time at the Toasty Coconut. We had four adults and a 9-month old, and the house included anything we could possibly need; beach chairs, tons of towels, pack n' play, a cooler, beach umbrella. I honestly can't think of anything that we needed that wasn't there when we arrived. The pool was clean and much larger than most private pools at other rentals.
Staying on the island itself was amazing, no traffic and the beach was not near as busy as any public beach I have ever been on. I can't wait to go back and we will definitely stay at the Toasty Coconut again.
Also, Ammey was very quick to respond to any questions I had and my deposit was returned in full within two days of checking out.
I see why many of the reviewers have been staying there for multiple years, it truly is a place you will want to return to.