Our group of seven had the most amazing time at Seabreeze Casa! Bea and Bob were very helpful in suggesting activities and grocery stores, and Bob even met us off the main highway to take us to the house. As others have mentioned 4x4s are necessary (we had a great experience with Vamos Rent a Car).
Seabreeze was perfect for our group, tucked away in the mountains with beautiful views, but only a short drive to the main road with restaurants and stores. The house and pool are well maintained, and we loved having the dogs keep us company. There is a horse stable where you can feed horses, and hiking paths Bob pointed us to.
Be sure to check out Tortilla Flats, and try the ceviche and coconuts they sell off the road!