My family and I rented The Maggie Cottage in May. We were attending our my daughter's graduation from Yale which is located in New Haven, an easy 30 minute drive. (Hotel rooms in New Haven were renting for $500 a night).
The cottage was clean, well located, easy to live in, well stocked with towels and kitchenware. The neighborhood was quiet, great pizza and breakfast close. The bathrooms were tiny, you'll need a plan for 8 adults to get a shower in the morning, but the water was hot! 8 guests in the bedrooms is a squeeze if all are adults, The Maggie cottage would be perfect for 2 couples and a few children.