My wife and I stayed at Naughty Pines for 3 days and 2 nights. We have visited Idyllwild several times over the years, renting different cabins each time and as nice as the others were, Paul's place is the best, hands down. It's the perfect combination of rustic, cabin in the woods vibe but without the common downsides you get with a "cabin in the woods". The house is amazing. Cozy, but roomy, everything works, the bathrooms are clean and have new fixtures. It's like a 4 star hotel but with the camping feel. Really the best of both worlds. The cherry on top is that the house is at the edge of the forest. Beautiful views that overlook the trees. One house to the left and none to the right. Very, very quiet and peaceful. It's located about 2 or 3 miles from town, a quick drive so that you're not far if you need to grab something from the store. I can't say enough good things. It's always a crap shoot when you rent a place and have no idea if the pictures will live up to your expectations - this exceeded ours. We will be back for sure!