For our honeymoon, we sought a destination that was private, beautiful, and had areas to explore. Long Island was definitely all three! Jeanie was a helpful and kind host. She provided advice and a list of all the best places to visit on the island. Grotto Bay itself is quiet and enjoyable. We happily cooked breakfast every morning in the outdoor kitchen... we had fun paddle-boating and kayaking (Jeanie's provides very nice equipment) and throwing horseshoes right on the beach just steps from our room. From what we saw during our week stay, we believe Grotto Bay is the best place to stay on Long Island for couples (rooms only have one bed).