Stayed at Off the Reef for one week in June 2014. It was exactly as advertised. Wish I could say the same for the island. If I was to return to Eleuthera, I'd stay here again, but that won't happen.
Had a couple of issues: TV didn't work most days, bring DVDs. No water for two nights, and backup system was broken, so I had to draw buckets of water from the cistern.