Top Fire Island Beaches

When summer arrives in New York City, it's time to get out to the beaches of Long Island. While everyone has their favorite beaches, Fire Island is one of the most beloved destinations on Long Island. There are many beaches to choose from on Fire Island, with each offering its own atmosphere and personality. While many visitors spend all their time on the beach adjacent to their vacation rental, there are also other beaches to explore if you're feeling adventurous. Here are some of the top Fire Island Beaches; descriptions might help you to choose the perfect spot on the island for you.

1. Fair Harbor

This Fire Island destination is known as a getaway from the urban grind of Manhattan. Attracting many urbanites, this spot is known for its restaurants, upscale food market, arts fair, and a bohemian spirit.

2. Fire Island Pines

If you're looking for some of the most expensive and luxurious real estate on the island, this is where you'll find it. Known for its markets, restaurants and boutiques, in addition to beaches - this is a place for travelers looking for more than just sand and surf.

3. Kismet

Travelers looking for nightlife should check out Kismet. One of the top Fire Island beaches, Kismet is home to a variety of happy hours, nightclubs, and house parties. There is also a marina here that is popular with boaters.

4. Ocean Bay Park

Another spot with a reputation for partying is Ocean Bay Park. Here you will find beach barbecues and all night parties at local bars. This destination attracts a number of young renters looking to blow off some steam.

5. Ocean Beach

While some destinations on Fire Island are known as sleepy little towns, Ocean Beach is exactly the opposite. This is known as the unofficial capital of Fire Island, and it is home to the largest concentration of houses, bars, and restaurants on the island.

6. Robins Rest

This sleepy town is perfect for travelers that want peace and quiet, but to be near all the amenities of Ocean Beach too. With many sand dune walkways here, you can really kick off your shoes and enjoy a peaceful summer getaway.

7. Saltaire

Families looking for a place in Fire Island will be drawn to Saltaire. This community is full of recreation opportunities for kids including basketball, tennis, and a boardwalk promenade. You won't find any late night parties here, just a relaxing atmosphere.

8. Seaview

Another kid-friendly destination on Fire Island is Seaview. With a playground, tennis courts, and beaches that are monitored by lifeguards, this is a great place to go if you're traveling with young children.

9. Lonelyville

If you're looking for top Fire Island beaches that deliver a serene environment, Lonelyville should be at the top of your list. If you want to get away from it all, the beach cottages here will do the trick. Neighboring communities offer nearby amenities, but here you will find all the peace and quiet you could ever need.

10. Davis Park

Some beaches on Fire Island are known as boating destinations, and Davis Park is one of them. Here visitors will find a huge marina, along with a casino, restaurants, and bars. You will find both family renters and younger renters in this Fire Island destination.

Fire Island Beach Rentals

Gorgeous 5 BR Beach House with Pool - 4th House from Ocean!

Immaculate and Gorgeous 5 bedroom beach house with POOL. Newly renovated kitchen, bathrooms and laundry. Spacious living room complete with wet bar, refrigerators, fireplace, and Direct TV Relaxation is a breeze whether you are lounging on the ...

Just Listed! Oceanfront! Modern Chic Beach House in Fire Island

Just Listed! Only one week left in August 8/1-8/8 Book September weeks & weekends now. Be among the first to stay in this brand new 2000 sq ft oceanfront property just completed for summer 2014. Situated on a quiet cul-de-sac next to the town of P...

Ocean Front Ocean View Six Bedrooms Perfect

Ours is truly one of the largest most desirable homes in Ocean Beach. It was originally built in 1925 and has been fully renovated. It has magnificent ocean views from the second and third floors. It is a great house to vacation in with extended...

Pool House On The Ocean

With only steps to the beach from this modern beach home you feel like your away at one of the finest hotels with the luxurious garden and grass on the 100'x105' property . (THIS HOME IS NOT LISTED ON CRAIG S LIST ) This is the only house in O...

Great 2 & 3 BR Villas accommodate up to 30+ in spectacular Kismet Fire Island

You’ll find the accommodations at Margarita Villas quite comfortable and affordable. We are located in Kismet, just steps from the ferry. Guests enjoy convenient access to the beach, playground, marina, tennis, dining and nightlife. Enjoy Bay and...

Vacation Home Search

Find the perfect rental for your vacation

Join Our Newsletter

Get the latest updates in your email